Steam workaround Edit
This achievement (along with the achievement Get 'em) is currently bugged because the game resets all achievement progress once the game is closed. As such the achievement may still be obtained by bountying 250 outlaws alive in a single session, without closing the game. Alternatively the player may use the quicksave system to quickly rack up 250 bounties, as the game also does not track individual bounties either. It only tracks the total number of bounties in a session, even after reloading a quicksave.
- Knock an outlaw unconscious early in the game.
- Bounty the outlaw alive.
- Repeat steps 3 and 4 249 times.
- Profit! Both Get 'em and Get 'em Goooooood! should now unlock.